BMW X5 vs Acura MDX: Which Luxury SUV is Right for You?
In this BMW X5 vs Acura MDX comparison, we’ll dive deep into the key differences between these two luxury SUVs. We’ll cover everything from performance and fuel economy to interior space, features, and pricing. By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of which vehicle better suits your needs and lifestyle.
BMW X5 vs Acura MDX: Performance
When it comes to performance, both the BMW X5 and Acura MDX offer powerful engine options. However, the BMW X5 edges out the MDX in terms of horsepower and towing capacity.
The base BMW X5 xDrive40i is powered by a 3.0-liter turbocharged inline-6 engine that produces 375 hp and 398 lb-ft of torque. This allows the X5 to accelerate from 0-60 mph in just 5.3 seconds. If you want even more power, the X5 M50i has a 4.4-liter twin-turbo V8 that cranks out 523 hp and 553 lb-ft of torque.
On the other hand, the Acura MDX comes standard with a 3.5-liter V6 engine that generates 290 hp and 267 lb-ft of torque. While respectable, it’s no match for the BMW’s performance. The MDX Type S trim level does get a boost with its 3.0-liter turbocharged V6 that makes 355 hp and 354 lb-ft of torque.
When it comes to towing, the BMW X5 can pull up to 7,200 lbs when properly equipped, while the Acura MDX tops out at 5,000 lbs of towing capacity.
Key Takeaways:
- BMW X5 has more powerful engine options up to 523 hp
- Acura MDX tops out at 355 hp with Type S trim
- X5 can tow up to 7,200 lbs vs MDX’s 5,000 lb max
If hauling and raw power are priorities, the BMW X5 is the clear winner in this category.
Fuel Economy: MDX vs X5
With great power often comes less-than-stellar fuel economy. So how do the BMW X5 and Acura MDX stack up in terms of gas mileage?
The 2024 BMW X5 xDrive40i gets an EPA-estimated 23 mpg city and 27 mpg highway. Opting for the more powerful M50i trim will drop those numbers to 16 mpg city and 22 mpg highway.
As for the 2024 Acura MDX, it achieves 19 mpg city and 26 mpg highway with front-wheel drive. Adding the all-wheel drive system only slightly decreases the highway fuel economy to 25 mpg.
So while the BMW X5 does have a slight edge in fuel efficiency, the difference isn’t huge, especially if you opt for the less powerful MDX. And if fuel savings are really important, both the BMW and Acura offer hybrid versions that get even better gas mileage.
Key Takeaways:
- BMW X5 gets up to 23/27 mpg (city/highway)
- Acura MDX gets up to 19/26 mpg (city/highway)
- Hybrid versions available for even better mpg
Overall, when it comes to fuel economy, there’s no clear winner – it mainly depends on which engine and drivetrain options you choose.
Interior Space and Cargo Room
One of the biggest factors to consider when shopping for a mid-size SUV is interior room and cargo space. After all, you want a vehicle that can comfortably accommodate your family and all your gear.
This is an area where the Acura MDX has a clear advantage over the BMW X5 thanks to its third-row seating. The MDX can seat up to 7 passengers across its three rows of seating. The X5, on the other hand, only has two rows that max out at 5 passengers.
When it comes to cargo room behind the third row, the MDX offers 18.1 cubic feet, while the X5 has 33.9 cubic feet behind its second row. Fold those rear seats down, however, and the MDX actually has a bit more maximum cargo room at 95 cubic feet versus 72.3 cubic feet in the BMW.
Passenger room in the first two rows is fairly comparable between the two SUVs. But if you frequently need to haul larger families or lots of cargo, the MDX is simply the more practical and versatile choice.
Key Takeaways:
- Acura MDX seats up to 7 with third-row, BMW X5 maxes at 5 seats
- MDX has 18.1 cu-ft cargo room behind third row
- With seats folded, MDX offers 95 cu-ft vs X5’s 72.3 cu-ft
So while the BMW X5 has less passenger space, it does offer a bit more cargo room behind its second row when all seats are in use.
Features and Technology
Both the BMW X5 and Acura MDX come loaded with the latest tech features you’d expect in a modern luxury SUV. But each one does have some unique advantages over the other.
The MDX really shines when it comes to its intuitive Acura True Touchpad Interface. This touchpad and 12.3-inch display combo allows you to control audio, navigation, and other functions without taking your eyes off the road. The BMW X5’s iDrive infotainment system is good, but the touchpad controller is simply more convenient.
Another standout feature on the Acura is its 9 Speaker ELS Studio Premium Audio system. Audiophiles will appreciate the rich, concert-like sound quality compared to the 10-speaker setup in the X5.
That said, BMW doesn’t hold back when it comes to advanced safety tech. The X5 offers front and rear automated emergency braking, lane keeping assist, blind spot monitoring, and more. Many of these are standard, whereas you’ll likely have to pay extra to get them on the MDX.
Both SUVs also offer plush, well-appointed cabins with leather upholstery, heated/cooled seats, panoramic moonroofs, and other great amenities. So neither falls short in the luxury department.
Key Takeaways:
- Acura MDX has intuitive True Touchpad Interface and premium audio
- BMW X5 offers more standard advanced safety features
- Both provide luxurious, feature-rich cabins
When it comes to tech, it really depends what’s most important to you – infotainment usability or advanced safety aids. Either way, you’re getting an upscale, well-equipped SUV.
Cost of Ownership
At the end of the day, pricing and overall costs are major factors in any big purchase like a new luxury SUV. How do the BMW X5 and Acura MDX compare in this regard?
The base 2024 Acura MDX starts around $51,500 MSRP for the front-wheel drive model. Add AWD and packages like the Advance and you can easily approach $60,000. The sportier MDX Type S trims kick off around $66,500.
Over on the BMW side, the 2024 X5 xDrive40i has a starting MSRP of $65,200. The more powerful M50i trim level starts at a lofty $85,400. Adding options and packages can drive the price well above $90,000 on higher trims.
So out of the gate, the Acura provides a more budget-friendly starting point. But prices can ramp up quickly when you start adding options and engine upgrades.
Beyond just the initial purchase price, the MDX will likely cost a bit less to maintain and insure over the years as well. BMWs tend to have higher ownership costs for routine maintenance, repairs, etc.
Key Takeaways:
- 2024 Acura MDX starts at $51,500 MSRP
- 2024 BMW X5 starts at $65,200 MSRP
- Lower maintenance/ownership costs for MDX
Unless you’re looking at a fully-loaded BMW, the MDX will be the more affordable choice upfront and likely long-term as well. But the X5’s higher pricing does get you more performance
The Verdict: BMW X5 vs Acura MDX
After comparing the BMW X5 and Acura MDX across all the key areas, it’s clear that each vehicle has its own strengths and weaknesses. Ultimately, the choice comes down to your specific needs and priorities.
If you prioritize performance and towing capability, the BMW X5 is the way to go. Its powerful engine options and higher towing capacity give it a clear edge over the MDX. The X5 is also slightly more fuel efficient in its base configuration.
However, if you need more interior space and versatility, the Acura MDX is the superior choice. Its third-row seating and slightly larger maximum cargo room make it a better family hauler. The MDX’s True Touchpad Interface and premium audio system are also high points.
From a pricing perspective, the Acura provides a more affordable entry point while still delivering plenty of luxury and features. But the BMW justifies its higher price tag with robust performance and an array of cutting-edge tech.
So in summary:
Choose the BMW X5 if:
- You want maximum power and towing capability
- Higher fuel efficiency is a priority
- You don’t need third-row seating
Go with the Acura MDX if:
- You need a versatile three-row SUV
- You prefer the value proposition
- User-friendly tech features are important
Honestly, you can’t go wrong with either of these stellar luxury SUVs from BMW and Acura. But prioritizing the areas most important to you will make the decision process easier.
Alternatives Worth Considering
Of course, the BMW X5 and Acura MDX aren’t the only games in town when it comes to premium mid-size SUVs. There are several other worthy alternatives to consider as well.
One is the Lexus RX, a pioneer in the luxury crossover space. It delivers signature Lexus build quality, reliability, and a plush, well-appointed interior. However, it lacks a third row and the performance chops of the X5 and MDX.
The Mercedes-Benz GLE is another heavyweight contender. Like the BMW, it offers blistering performance from its AMG models. But it also provides a more spacious three-row option along with the latest Mercedes tech.
If you want to stand out, the Genesis GV80 is a relative newcomer delivering incredible value and styling. It matches the Germans for luxury while costing thousands less.
Other potential alternatives include the Audi Q7, Volvo XC90, Lincoln Aviator, and Infiniti QX60.
At the end of the day, the luxury SUV market is filled with excellent choices for discerning buyers. Taking the time to carefully test drive and compare top models like the X5 and MDX will help you find the perfect fit.
Final Thoughts
There’s a reason the BMW X5 and Acura MDX consistently rank among the top luxury mid-size SUVs year after year. Both deliver exceptional overall packages that hit high marks across the board.
For many shoppers, the decision will come down to performance versus practicality. The X5 is the clear winner if you want pulse-raising power and decent fuel efficiency. But the MDX counters with its more family-friendly interior and value pricing.
Whichever you choose, you’re getting a premium SUV with a well-appointed cabin, cutting-edge tech, and the driving satisfaction you’d expect from BMW and Acura. Take the time to test drive both and prioritize which areas like power, space, and pricing are most important to you.
With so many great options available, there’s a luxury mid-size SUV out there that will check every box on your list. Happy shopping! Copy
