BMW i4 vs i5: Comparing Electric Driving Excellence

Are you considering switching to an electric vehicle (EV) and torn between the BMW i4 and i5? In this detailed guide, we’ll explore the key differences between these two popular EVs to help you decide which one better suits your needs and preferences.

The BMW i4 and i5 are both high-performance, all-electric vehicles that offer a luxurious driving experience. However, they differ in terms of size, design, range, performance, and features. By the end of this article, you’ll have a clear understanding of the pros and cons of each model, enabling you to make an informed decision.

Design and Exterior Styling

The BMW i4 and i5 have distinct exterior designs that cater to different tastes. Here’s how they compare:

BMW i4:

• Sportier and more contemporary look
• Vertically oriented kidney grille
• Aggressively sloping roofline
• Hatchback design for easier cargo loading

BMW i5:

• More traditional BMW design cues
• Larger kidney grille
• Longer and taller body
• Sedan body style with a trunk

While the i4 has a more modern and aggressive appearance, the i5 showcases a classic BMW design language. The choice between the two may come down to personal preference and whether you prioritize a sporty or more luxurious look.

Interior Space and Comfort

When it comes to interior space and comfort, the larger dimensions of the BMW i5 give it an edge over the i4. Let’s take a closer look:

BMW i4:

• Seating for up to 5 passengers
• Decent legroom and headroom in the front
• Slightly cramped rear seating, especially for taller passengers
• 10 cubic feet of cargo space

BMW i5:

• Seating for up to 5 passengers
• More generous legroom and headroom in both rows
• Rear seats offer more space and comfort
• 17.3 cubic feet of cargo space

If you frequently carry passengers or need extra cargo room, the BMW i5 may be the better choice. However, if it’s primarily you and occasional passengers, the i4 could be sufficient.

Range and Battery

One of the most crucial factors when choosing an EV is the range and battery capacity. Here’s how the BMW i4 and i5 compare:

BMW i4:

• Available with a 70kWh or 83.9kWh battery
• Range of up to 358 miles (EPA estimated) with the 83.9kWh battery
• Charging time varies based on battery size and charging method

BMW i5:

• Comes standard with an 84kWh battery
• Range of up to 362 miles (EPA estimated)
• Charging time similar to the i4 with the larger battery

While the range difference between the two models is minimal, the i5 has a slight advantage with its larger standard battery. However, the i4 offers more flexibility with its battery options, allowing you to choose between range and cost.

Performance and Driving Dynamics

Both the BMW i4 and i5 are designed to deliver an exhilarating driving experience, but with slightly different approaches. Here’s how they stack up:

BMW i4:

• Available in several performance variants, including the high-performance M50
• 0-60 mph times ranging from 5.8 seconds (base model) to 3.7 seconds (M50)
• Rear-wheel drive or all-wheel drive (xDrive) configurations
• Lighter weight for improved agility and handling

BMW i5:

• Available in two main variants: eDrive40 and high-performance M60
• 0-60 mph times of 5.7 seconds (eDrive40) and 3.6 seconds (M60)
• Rear-wheel drive or all-wheel drive (xDrive) configurations
• Larger and heavier, with a focus on stability and comfort

If you’re a driving enthusiast who prioritizes performance and agility, the BMW i4, especially the M50 variant, might be the better choice. However, if you prefer a more planted and luxurious driving experience, the i5 could be a better fit.

Features and Technology

Both the BMW i4 and i5 come equipped with the latest technology and features, but there are some notable differences:

BMW i4:

• Standard features include LED headlights, a panoramic sunroof, and a curved display with the latest iDrive system
• Optional features like a Harman Kardon premium sound system, heated seats, and a head-up display
• Available with BMW’s Driving Assistance Professional package for advanced driver aids

BMW i5:

• Comes standard with a Harman Kardon premium sound system and a wireless device charging tray
• Features a futuristic Interaction Bar with ambient lighting and gesture controls
• Offers advanced driver assistance features like BMW’s Highway Assistant and Remote Parking Assistant
• Available with a Sky Lounge Roof and a Bowers & Wilkins premium sound system (optional)

While the i4 offers a more comprehensive list of optional features, the i5 comes better equipped from the base model. If you prefer a more tech-laden and futuristic interior experience, the i5 may have an edge.

Pricing and Value

Finally, let’s take a look at the pricing and value proposition of the BMW i4 and i5:

BMW i4:

• Base model starts at around $53,000 MSRP
• Higher trim levels like the M50 can reach over $65,000
• Generally more affordable than the i5, especially when considering similar feature levels

BMW i5:

• Base model starts at around $66,800 MSRP
• The high-performance M60 variant can exceed $84,000
• More expensive due to its larger size and additional standard features

While the BMW i5 is more expensive, it offers more interior space, a higher level of standard equipment, and a more luxurious overall package. However, if you’re working within a tighter budget or prioritize performance over luxury, the i4 may provide better value for your money.

In Conclusion

Choosing between the BMW i4 and i5 ultimately comes down to your specific needs, preferences, and budget. The i4 is the more affordable option, with a sportier design and impressive performance, particularly in the higher trim levels. It’s an excellent choice for driving enthusiasts or those who prioritize agility and handling.

On the other hand, the i5 is the larger and more luxurious option, offering more interior space, advanced features, and a more comfortable and planted driving experience. If you frequently carry passengers or value a more premium interior experience, the i5 may be worth the additional cost.

Regardless of your choice, both the BMW i4 and i5 represent the pinnacle of electric vehicle engineering, combining cutting-edge technology with the brand’s renowned driving dynamics and luxury. By carefully considering your priorities and the key differences outlined in this guide, you can make an informed decision and enjoy the ultimate electric driving experience.